As Christ's messenger Paul's authority was beyond dispute.
As Christ's messengers it is never right to lord it over those entrusted to us (1 Peter 5:3 ). Never let it be our condemnation that
As those with spiritual "authority", that is, 'exousia' meaning freedom of action, we are to use our spiritual authority to build up, not for destruction -
or tearing down ( 2 Corinthians 10:8 ). When Christ's spokesmen have to speak into a sinful situation and there is no repentance, he speaks
for Jesus and it will be Jesus who in His power punishes (2 Corinthians 13:1-4 ). Paul could have commanded the Christlike action that
Philemon needed to take in regard to Onesimus. He chose to "beseech " "for love's sake" (Philemon 9 KJV). As a number of commentators
point out Paul is not referring to the love of Philemon for him, nor Paul's for Philemon.
Motivated by that love that does not seek its own (1 Corinthians 13:5 ). Philemon would do what was fitting (Philemon 8 ), and so
will we. Paul strengthened his appeal - "for love's sake" with reference to his personal condition.
By appealing as PAUL he was bringing attention to his success in the gospel. As "the aged" he was bringing attention to being a serving veteran in
the gospel. As "a prisoner" he was bringing attention to his sufferings in the gospel. Such was Paul's condition he had the right to speak and expect
Philemon to receive what he said with respect, and willingness of mind to comply.
Paul again appeals, and now makes his purpose and request in a direct manner. Onesimus was special to Paul in that he had begotten him through
the gospel (1 Corinthians 4:15 ).He is therefore Paul's son in the gospel. There is no hint here that Paul had any power of his own to
regenerate anyone. What is magnified is the power of the gospel unto salvation (Romans 1:16 ). Such that believe the good news and
receive Jesus are born again of the Spirit (John 1:12-13; 3:6-8 ). Paul's imprisonment linked with Onesimus's new birth made their
relationship all the more precious - and reference to the circumstances would touch Philemon with tenderness and praise to God for a number of
things that were highlighted:
Like Philemon we should be deeply affected by the manifestation of the Spirit of Jesus in the Lord's prisoner.
It would appear that Philemon was a successful businessman, and as such would not be interested in an unprofitable deal. Paul in this positive way
assures him of the profitability of receiving Onesimus back. Paul is also emphasising the positive change that takes place when Christ is received
into the life.
Proof of the positive change in Onesimus, lay in the testimony that Paul now found him profitable. Onesimus was not a reformed, rehabilitated, nor
re-educated man - he was recreated, a new creation living in vital union with Christ Jesus (2 Corinthians 5:17; Colossians 2:6-7 ). Paul had
come to love changed Onesimus so much it was a great struggle to send him away, possibly not to see him again. Paul's heart went with him. One
so regarded needed to be treated tenderly.
How revealing this is of Paul's commitment to another's rights! Philemon had priority to the service of Onesimus, Paul's desires were secondary
(Philemon 13 ). We are to do what is right in our dealings with others (1 John 2:29; 3:7 ), even if doing what is right is to our own
hurt.
Though Paul could argue a good case for retaining Onesimus, he would not without obtaining proper consent. How careful leadership must be not to
violate a believer's freedom to make their own decisions in matters where their rights are concerned. Beware of presuming on what would be the
intentions of someone. There is another good reason given by Paul for not acting without the other's consent:
Philemon's good deed in receiving Onesimus must not be tainted by manipulation, or forced. Rather, it had to be his own free act of generosity, then
it would be an expression of the loving kindness of Christ that indwelt him. Voluntary actions of kindness are a display of the character of God
(Luke 6:35; Colossians 3:12 ). Exercising constraint over fellow believers in opportunities for service and mercy, robs them of fulfilling their
responsibilities, hinders their reliability in obeying God, and steals from them their reward (Revelation 3:11 ).
In no way is Onesimus's misdemeanour to be excused - but neither should the overruling hand of God be ignored. Even those things in which we
have been disadvantaged can by God, be turned to our advantage (Romans 8:28 ). Temporary relationship can be broken by sin, but grace
can so work in its place a new relationship that is forever, an eternal relationship that is in Christ Jesus.
Grace does not stop serving, but it changes our service to that of serving as brothers. Both the serving brother and the served master are
accountable to their Lord (Colossians 3:22; 4:1 ). Relationships in the family of God are to be valued as precious - remember that in ministry
to one another we minister to the Lord Himself (Matthew 25:45 ). There are special relationships. Onesimus was a beloved brother to Paul,
but was more so to Philemon,
The double relationship was that in the flesh he had a serving brother, and in the Lord he had a servant for a brother. When we value our
relationship we will fulfill the responsibilities they carry (Ephesians 6:5-9; Luke 12:48 ).
4. SHUNNING OFFICIOUS COMMANDING BY
APPEALING SINCERELY (PHILEMON 8-17)
Philemon 9 "Yet for love's sake I rather
beseech thee, ..."
4.1. PAUL CHOSE TO APPEAL (Philemon 8-9)
Philemon 8 "Therefore, though I might
be very bold in Christ to command you what is fitting,"
Ezekiel 34:4 "... with force and with
cruelty have ye ruled them."
Lightfoot says, the reference is to "love absolutely, love regarded as a principle which demands a
deferential respect." J.B. Lightfoot - Colossians and to Philemon -
Zondervan
Philemon 9 "... being such an one as Paul
the aged, and now also a prisoner of Jesus Christ."
4.2. PAUL DIRECT IN APPEALING (Philemon 10)
Philemon 10 "... for my son Onesimus,
whom I have begotten in my bonds:"

Paul was bound but the gospel was not. 
Paul was in chains but his spirit was sweet. 
Paul was confined but made the most of opportunities to
witness. 
Paul was in privation but was bountiful towards others. 
Paul was in affliction but was experiencing God's blessing. 
Paul was not free but wanted his son's full freedom. 
Paul was disadvantaged but sought fairness for another. 4.3. PAUL POSITIVE IN APPEALING (Philemon 11-
14)
Philemon 11 "who once was
unprofitable to you, but now is profitable to you and to me."
"Paul also used a play on words which first century readers would have found very humorous. "Onesimus"
means "profitable", as does 'chrestos'. In this verse Paul says the runaway has been achrestos (useless), but now will prove
euchrestos (useful)." L.O. Richards - Bible Readers Companion - Victor
Books
"Christianity knows nothing of hopeless cases. It professes its ability to take the most crooked stick and
bring it straight, toflash a new power into the blackest carbon, which will turn it into a diamond." Alexander
Maclaren - Colossians and Philemon - Hodder and Stoughton,
1888
Philemon 12 "I am sending him back.
You therefore receive him, that is, my own heart,"
Philemon 14 "But without your consent I
wanted to do nothing, ..."
Philemon 14 "... that your good deed
might not be by compulsion, as it were, but voluntary."
4.4. PAUL ENLIGHTENING IN APPEALING (Philemon
15-16)
Philemon 15 "For perhaps he therefore
departed for a season, that thou shouldest receive him for ever; "
Philemon 16 "Not now as a servant, but
above a servant, a brother beloved, ..."
Philemon 16 "... both in the flesh, and in
the Lord? "